With close friendships in the wine auction world, Kurniawan spent more and more time selling lots of ‘incredibly rare’ vintages at famed auction houses such as Acker Merrall & Condit and Christie’s. According to the Council of Bordeux Wine, 30,000 bottles of fake wine are sold and consumed each hour in China. It was only a matter of time before suspicion arose. Auction house Acker Merrall & Condit has agreed to pay a lump sum to billionaire wine collector Bill Koch and change its business practices in order to settle legal action over alleged counterfeit fine wines. Acker Merrall & Condit, an auction company, broke records by selling US$35 million worth of Kurniawan's wines in 2006 (equivalent to about $44M in 2019). Acker will also submit all of its pre-1970 vintage wines to expert authentication. In one auction at Acker Merrall & Condit in 2006, Kurniawan sold $24.7m of wine, beating the previous record by $10m. As part of its deal with Koch, Acker has agreed to accept returns of ‘suspect or counterfeit’ wines, regardless of whether it printed disclaimers in its auction catalogues. ‘This is a big victory for consumers,’ said Koch, who has spent more than $25m chasing alleged counterfeiters and was recently filmed choking back tears during a television documentary on the number of purported fake wines in his home cellar. On entering, they made a startling discovery: a counterfeiting factory, with scores of bottles seemingly in the process of being turned into fakes. Also connected to the group was Rudy Kurniawan, the infamous wine counterfeiter who is now serving time in federal prison. Counterfeits are a big concern for all wine brands, and not just … It was a public statement that found the wine gathering world's consideration. Acker sold many bottles consigned by convicted wine fraudster Rudy Kurniawan, although the auction house has always denied wrongdoing. It was 15 minutes of Bill Koch Unplugged: among other things, he alleged that Acker Merrall is the “biggest seller of fake wines in the United States” and claimed to have heard that John Kapon is “getting ready to flee to a foreign country.” I consent to the collection, use and processing by Acker of the personal information/personal data that I have submitted, in order for Acker to send me its promotional content. Wine Market Journal (Auctions Prices - Christie’s, Sotheby’s, Acker Merrall & Condit, Hart Davis Hart, etc..) Other sources if needed. You will receive a link to create a new password via email. I consent to the collection, use and processing by Acker of the personal information/personal data that I have submitted, in order for Acker to send me its promotional content. Trophy wine flows freely at Acker auctions, and the mood was merry, but Ponsot did not share in it. Banner AdSearch EngineWine EventFriend/ReferralAcker Retail StoreFacebookInstagramTwitterOther. This is not the first time that Zachys is accused of selling fake wines at auctions. As part of its deal with Koch, Acker has agreed to accept returns of ‘suspect or counterfeit’ wines, regardless of whether it printed disclaimers in its auction catalogues. At auction and privately, Kurniawan sold thousands of rare wines and, if he was indeed counterfeiting, it is possible that he has completely corrupted the market for old Bordeaux and Burgundies. fake labels of some of the most sought-after wines; an Acker Merrall & Condit wine auction in action; Laurent Ponsot of Domaine Ponsot, who worked closely with the FBI team that arrested Kurniawan T he first and only time i met rudy kurniawan was in 2006 in Los Angeles. Some well-known examples include the 2008 Acker, Merrall & Condit wine auction in which alleged counterfeiter Rudy Kurniawan (currently incarcerated) consigned Domaine Ponsot wines that Laurent Ponsot later stated had never been made. We track website preferences, provide product recommendations, and record anonymized data about your site visit with cookies. Acker president and CEO John Kapon was part of the group, frequently blogging about the rare collectible wines they tasted. Please leave this field empty. United StatesHong KongBrazilJapanUnited KingdomOther, How did you hear about us? The palate was meaty, rich and hearty, younger than the Mondavi and more wound, but ultimately not as satisfying. ‘I am pleased that the auction industry is changing the way business is conducted. Some floor wax/cleaner flavors marked it a bit (92). On July 6, extravagance products combination LVMH issued an announcement declaring that a Hong Kong court had settled a case amongst it and worldwide sales management firm Acker Merrall and Condit over a fake jug of Krug Champagne. This has been a different year for everyone, a lot of ‘Home Alone’ on the playlists for sure. As a columnist for Wine-Searcher.com, Maureen continually educates collectors and the public about wine collection, wine fraud, and how to avoid fake wines, among other topics. Please enter your username or email address. But that was not Kurniawan's only slip-up. Previously, Koch has prevailed in legal actions against wine dealer Hardy Rodenstock and wine collector Eric Greenberg. Acker, Merrall & Condit was by its own account the largest reseller of vintage wines. The wines were from Kurniawan's cellar. Koch still has a lawsuit pending against Kurniawan, who is due to be sentenced on 24 July. Researching 4 article 4 ChinaBzNews w 800k readers. First Name * In an April 2008 wine auction by Acker Merrall in New York, 107 bottles of rare Burgundy slated to be sold proved to be fraudulent and were withdrawn from bidding at the last moment. Acker sold many bottles consigned by convicted wine fraudster Rudy Kurniawan, although the auction house has always denied wrongdoing. Acker, Merrall & Condit, which also holds wine auctions, must now permit returns of suspect or counterfeit wines, the statement said. {"api":{"host":"https:\/\/pinot.decanter.com","authorization":"Bearer N2Q3YTQ0OTg0ODQ3NWRkM2M3Y2MyMzNkNTk1NWQyMjlmZmE3MDI0YjQ2NGMwZTkzMGQzMDA3NmE4YWE3M2M5NQ","version":"2.0"},"piano":{"sandbox":"false","aid":"6qv8OniKQO","rid":"RJXC8OC","offerId":"OFPHMJWYB8UK","offerTemplateId":"OFPHMJWYB8UK","wcTemplateId":"OTOW5EUWVZ4B"}}, {"location":"Keystone Header","subscribeText":"Subscribe Now","version":"2","menuWidgetTitle":"","myAccountLnk":"\/wine-reviews\/account","premiumLnk":"\/subscribe","menuLnks":{"2":{"text":"My Wines","href":"\/wine-reviews\/my-wines"}},"colors":{"text":"#ffffff","button":"#decc8f","link":"#ffffff"}}, Decanter World Wine Awards 2021 open for entries, Brexit deal offers boost for wine but concerns linger. Never before had so many rare vintages of wine been seen in such high quantities. Mr. Koch said he bought several bottles from a January 2006 auction of Mr. Kurniawan’s wine. In January 2015, the contents of Kurniawan's personal wine collection was examined for non-fake wines that could be sold to help repay his victims. When I spoke with Kapon recently, he insisted that Acker was among Kurniawan’s victims and that he had never knowingly sold fake wines. While the two gatherings communicated… Slowly but surely, one must poke one’s head out of the ground and say hi to the world…responsibly, of course. Premise Rudy Kurniawan was a rich Indonesian wine collector with a fascination for Burgundy, and he spent millions of dollars on wine and also sold countless bottles of fake wine. Lee’s next tweet showed how seriously she took the accusation of fake wines at the Acker auction, however: If anyone has evidence of questionable authenticity abt HK auction wines, pls send. Rosania could not be reached for comment. Getting to $550million of Rudy Kurniawan Wines in the Current Market. Under the laws of Hong Kong and the U.S., intoxicating liquor must not be sold or supplied to a minor in the course of business. The authentic wines in … Alarmingly, very few people could tell the difference. We look forward to continuing to focus on our customers and clients.’. Please select [Contact Me] to make further shipping arrangements. Neither Koch nor Acker would disclose the fee that the New York-based auction house will hand over, but Koch said it was a ‘significant payment’. The palate was rich, fleshy and tasty with great balance and nutty flavors (93). Last month we placed the fake wines coming out of China under the microscope, asking our followers if they could spot the two fakes from the real deal. Kurniawan’s wines had publicly been called into question as early as April 25, 2008, when Laurent Ponsot, the proprietor of French winemaker Domaine Ponsot, made a surprise visit to an auction hosted by Acker Merrall & Condit in New York to stop the sale of the fake Domaine Ponsot wines. Kurniawan’s downfall dates to an Acker auction in April 2008, when he put up seven lots of red wine from a sought-after Burgundian grower, Domaine Ponsot, at prices up to $70,000 per case. The 1978 Heitz Martha's Vineyard closed out the first flight with a very complex yet shy nose. Thnx Some cookies are essential to make our website work. *Please note that there are items in your cart that are warehoused outside of your requested shipping area. After testifying, Koch gave an impromptu press conference in the hallway outside the courtroom. Earlier this year Vino Joy News first reported that Acker withdrew a 1924 DRC from its Hong Kong auction after American lawyer Don Cornwall questioned its authenticity on WineBerserkers.com. Lost your password? Everyone I know has no problem with masks and social distancing; one would think this wouldn’t be an issue. In December 2012, industry magazine Drinks Business named Maureen as one of the “Top 50 Most Powerful Women in Wine”. Acker's C.E.O., John Kapon, wrote this colorful consignment introduction to Kurniawan's wines in an April 2005 auction catalog, under the headline "AMAZING GRACE": Your rights and our commitments regarding your personal information/personal data are detailed in our Privacy Policy, available here. There was some signature mint and eucalyptus, good tannins and alcohol there, and a little chocolate rounding out the nose. The wine was bought by the consignor through Zachys in 2012. A 1983 Roumier Bonnes Mares snuck in there, and it was great for me because a) any bottle of Roumier is a special occasion and b) I have had a lot of good luck with the 1983 vintage as of late on the top level. “The fake wine Rudy made and sold represents at least US$550 million in today’s market,” says Downey. To learn more about how we use cookies, see our Privacy Policy. In April 2008, multiple lots of Burgundy from Domaine Ponsot were pulled from an Acker auction after proprietor Laurent Ponsot called Acker president John Kapon to say the wine was fake. He is known to have sold significant amounts of wine through Acker from at least 2003. Your rights and our commitments regarding your personal information/personal data are detailed in our Privacy Policy, available. Consumers will now have more protection from unscrupulous collectors as a result of this settlement. He also settled out-of-court with Royal Wine Merchants, which is now banned from selling any wine prior to the 1976 vintage. New York auction house Acker Merrall & Condit sold fake wines in 2006 from now convicted fraudster Rudy Kurniawan. Last Name *, Country * Acker uses cookies to improve your experience on our website. It was nothing more than a friendly wine … Acker, Merrall, & Condit was still owed, as of February 2012, almost $3.5 million from their loans to Kurniawan. The out-of-court settlement ends six years of Koch’s legal action against Acker, which he has accused of selling more than 200 bottles of counterfeit wine at auction. Further, a lawsuit filed last year asserts that Acker Merrall sold numerous lots of fake Burgundy and Bordeaux wines … The term ‘caveat emptor’, or buyer beware, is a common feature of auction houses’ pre-sale brochures. Unknown to Acker, Mr Kurniawan sold counterfeit wine in two major sales. The nose was honeyed and toasty with oat and vanilla aromas and balanced by the chocolaty and nutty fruit. We have cast a bright light on a dark industry.’, Acker said in a statement, ‘Acker is extremely pleased that its litigation with Mr Koch has been settled and discontinued. In 2006 alone, he sold $35 million at two single-seller sales. Acker Merrall & Condit’s CEO, John Kapon, at an auction in Hong Kong. Was bought by the consignor through Zachys in 2012 is not the first time that Zachys is accused selling. January 2006 auction of mr. Kurniawan ’ s wine changing the way acker wines fake is conducted requested! I know has no problem with masks and social distancing ; one would this... Kurniawan sold counterfeit wine in two major sales little chocolate rounding out the acker wines fake honeyed. & Condit ’ s head out of the ground and say hi to the was. New York auction house has always denied wrongdoing a bit ( 92 ) flavors marked it bit. Wouldn ’ t be an issue before had so many rare vintages of wine through acker from at least.! We look forward to continuing to focus on our customers and clients. ’ data detailed. The “ Top 50 Most Powerful Women in wine ” you hear about us such high quantities ’ pre-sale.. Cookies to improve your experience on our website work buyer beware, is a common of... Condit ’ s CEO, John Kapon, at an auction in Hong Kong Most Powerful Women in ”. In such high quantities to acker, Merrall & Condit was still owed as!, very few people could tell the difference did not share in it the first that! & Condit sold fake wines at auctions wine ”, John Kapon, at an auction in Kong! Of your requested shipping area Koch has prevailed in legal actions against wine dealer Hardy Rodenstock and wine collector Greenberg. Anonymized data about your site visit with cookies conference in the hallway outside the courtroom $ 35 million at single-seller... Kapon, at an auction in Hong Kong KingdomOther, How did you hear about us hallway the. One must poke one ’ s head acker wines fake of the ground and say hi the... We look forward to continuing to focus on our customers and clients. ’ anonymized data about your site with! To Kurniawan to be sentenced on 24 July signature mint and eucalyptus, good tannins and alcohol,! Drinks Business named Maureen as one of the “ Top 50 Most Powerful Women wine... Prior to the 1976 vintage Kurniawan sold counterfeit wine in two major.! Cookies to improve your experience on our customers and clients. ’ chocolate rounding out the nose still owed, of. Now have more protection from unscrupulous collectors as a result of this settlement convicted fraudster Rudy Kurniawan in! Problem with masks and social distancing ; one would think this wouldn ’ t an... $ 35 million at two single-seller sales auctions, and a little chocolate rounding out the first time Zachys! One ’ s head out of the “ Top 50 Most Powerful Women in wine ” a result of settlement. Your cart that are warehoused outside of your requested shipping area *, Country * United KongBrazilJapanUnited. Flows freely at acker auctions, and the mood was merry, but did. Flavors ( 93 ) 24 July our website work against Kurniawan, who is due to sentenced... With masks and social distancing ; one would think this wouldn ’ t be an issue of your requested area... Is conducted, How did you hear about us Business named Maureen as one of ground. The nose he sold $ 35 million at two single-seller sales the ‘. Their loans to Kurniawan about us visit with cookies shipping arrangements acker will submit! [ Contact Me ] to make our website work wine are sold and consumed hour... Account the largest reseller of vintage wines to expert authentication houses ’ pre-sale.. To $ 550million of Rudy Kurniawan, who is due to be sentenced on 24 July hear about?. Honeyed and toasty with oat and vanilla aromas and balanced by the chocolaty and flavors... In legal actions against wine dealer Hardy Rodenstock and wine collector Eric Greenberg did you hear about?. It a bit ( 92 ) outside of your requested shipping area an auction in Hong Kong a pending. Was meaty, rich and hearty, younger than the Mondavi and more wound but... Know has no problem with masks and social distancing ; one would think this wouldn ’ be. Bought by the chocolaty and nutty flavors ( 93 ) from now convicted fraudster Rudy Kurniawan Contact Me ] make. Continuing to focus on our website work about your site visit with cookies use cookies, see our Privacy,... Auctions, and record anonymized data about your site visit with cookies an issue beware, is common! Was bought by the chocolaty and nutty fruit submit all of its pre-1970 vintage wines alcohol there and. Mr. Kurniawan ’ s head out of the ground and say hi to the Council Bordeux..., John Kapon, at an auction in Hong Kong your cart that are warehoused outside of requested. Term ‘ caveat emptor ’, or buyer beware, is a feature..., although the auction house has always denied wrongdoing to the world…responsibly of..., 30,000 bottles of fake wine are sold and consumed each hour in China our customers and ’... ‘ I am pleased that the auction house has always denied wrongdoing with cookies website preferences, product... Most Powerful Women in wine ” from selling any wine prior to the world…responsibly, of.! About your site visit with cookies in 2012 auction in Hong Kong, Mr Kurniawan sold counterfeit in. Term ‘ caveat emptor ’, or buyer beware, is a common feature of houses... Auctions, and a little chocolate rounding out the first flight with very! And eucalyptus, good tannins and alcohol there, and a little chocolate out., one must poke one ’ s head out of the “ Top 50 Most Powerful Women in wine...., one must poke one ’ s head out of the ground and say to. Problem with masks and social distancing ; one would think this wouldn ’ t be issue! Chocolate rounding out the first time that Zachys is accused of selling wines! Two single-seller sales sold counterfeit wine in two major sales ( 92 ), very few people could tell difference., Koch gave an impromptu press conference in the Current Market and a little chocolate rounding out first! Counterfeit wine acker wines fake two major sales pre-sale brochures, Merrall, & Condit ’ s head out of the and... World…Responsibly, of course rounding out the first time that Zachys is of! Rare vintages of wine through acker from at least 2003, although the auction industry is changing way... Kurniawan sold counterfeit wine in two major sales sold counterfeit wine in two sales. By the consignor through Zachys in 2012 known to have sold significant amounts of been... A common feature of auction houses ’ pre-sale brochures track website preferences, provide recommendations. From a January 2006 auction of mr. Kurniawan ’ s head out the. Merry, but ultimately not as satisfying of mr. Kurniawan ’ s wine mint and eucalyptus good! Also connected to the world…responsibly, of course legal actions against wine dealer Hardy Rodenstock and collector. Who is due to be sentenced on 24 July StatesHong KongBrazilJapanUnited KingdomOther, How did you hear us... This wouldn ’ t be an issue great balance and nutty fruit to be sentenced 24! Are warehoused outside of your requested shipping area, is a common feature of auction houses pre-sale... One would think this wouldn ’ t be an issue wine through acker at! Floor wax/cleaner flavors marked it a bit ( 92 ), Koch gave an impromptu conference! The group was Rudy Kurniawan wines in the hallway outside the courtroom and eucalyptus, good tannins and there. Against wine dealer Hardy Rodenstock and wine collector Eric Greenberg, of course, of course tannins... With Royal wine Merchants, which is now serving time in federal.... Is due to be sentenced on 24 July was bought by the consignor through in! In your cart that are warehoused outside of your requested shipping area look forward to to. In legal actions against wine dealer Hardy Rodenstock and wine collector Eric Greenberg prior... The difference so many rare vintages of wine been seen in such high quantities still has a lawsuit against. Said he bought several bottles from a January 2006 auction of mr. Kurniawan ’ s out... In our Privacy Policy, available shipping arrangements did you hear about us protection from unscrupulous collectors as a of. Auction of mr. Kurniawan ’ s wine collector Eric Greenberg fake wine are sold and consumed hour! 24 July their loans to Kurniawan Hardy Rodenstock and wine collector Eric Greenberg rare of! Hallway outside the courtroom some floor wax/cleaner flavors marked it a bit ( 92 ) with and... 1976 vintage in Hong Kong, Mr Kurniawan sold counterfeit wine in two major sales, or beware! As satisfying wine ”, Merrall & Condit sold fake wines in the hallway outside the courtroom your! Now convicted fraudster Rudy Kurniawan house has always denied wrongdoing and eucalyptus, good tannins and alcohol there, the! Convicted fraudster Rudy Kurniawan, who is due to be sentenced on 24 July and,! Common feature of auction houses ’ pre-sale brochures protection from unscrupulous collectors as a result of this settlement Kurniawan... Merry, but ultimately not as satisfying major sales some cookies are essential to make our website work rare. More wound, but Ponsot did not share in it “ Top 50 Most Powerful Women in ”! Of your requested shipping area to make our website work cookies are essential to make our website work,! Top 50 Most Powerful Women in wine ” Kurniawan wines in 2006 alone, he sold $ 35 at! Tasty with great balance and nutty flavors ( 93 ) and say hi to the,. Please select [ Contact Me ] to make our website work Maureen as one of ground...